By Phil Power - February 23, 2007
It is easy enough to pick on politicians -- and I certainly have done so, many more times than once.
But we need to remember that they are human beings as well. Pause for a moment to consider the kinds of pressures our elected leaders in Lansing have to withstand during these tough times.
Most of them -- like most of us, have kids and spouses that need and deserve their time and attention. They have the kinds of worries - financial, career, personal - that afflict every one of us.
But unlike us, they're in the Capitol, the pressure cooker of our troubled state, facing an extra set of burdens and responsibilities.
Sure, they volunteered for this duty, but it's tough duty nevertheless. They are paid better than most of their colleagues in other states -- $79,500 a year -- but most could do better elsewhere.
They expect to have their performance criticized. But it's deeply unfair to make it personal, to assault their characters.
New York Times columnist David Brooks, one of the most thoughtful and insightful folks around, detailed just why in a recent column: "In our democracy, lawmakers are compelled to spend their days maneuvering for trivial advantages that nobody will remember by dinnertime...
"In our democracy, top officials lead frantic, overscheduled lives, with almost no time alone and with major decisions made by instinct during rushed limo rides from one forgettable event to another. They spend their days talking, and pretty soon they become human jukeboxes - their snippets of conversation are just chunks of oft-repeated material they have retrieved from the stump speech audio collection in their heads...
"Our democracy, at least as it has evolved, takes individuals who are reasonable in private and it churns them through a public process that is almost tailor-made to undermine their virtues.
"The process of perpetually kissing up to the voters destroys the leadership qualities the voters are looking for in the first place: tranquility of spirit, independence of mind, and a sensitivity to the contours and complexity of reality."
Amen!
We need to keep all thatin mind, as we take a moment to consider in greater detail the pressures that face our governor and everyone else we've elected, especially the legislature:
The fact is that Michigan is in terrible trouble. Our economy stinks. Our state budget is awash in red ink, and big decisions about how to plug the holes have to be made within just a few months. Those decisions will have enormous consequences.
The very future of our Michigan is up for grabs, as it never has been before.
We can become "Michissippi," with, yes, low taxes -- and poorly paid workers, a lousy education system, few state services and crummy economic prospects . . . plus cold weather.
Or we can restructure our government, cut unnecessary spending, reform our tax system and find the revenue we need. The money we need, that is, to fund an investment program in our durable, distinctive competitive assets like our universities, our "North Coast" environment and the skills and brains of our people.
The special interests (what organization, after all, is not a special interest?) are already aroused and shouting. They are stirring up citizen unease about a two percent sales tax on services. The anti-taxers-no-matter-what are threatening recall campaigns.
The din grows, the pressure rises. And our public officials are plunk in the middle of the pressure cooker.
Meanwhile, in our state capital, in private, everyone acknowledges how complicated and how serious the choices are.
Our public officials know full well that we are approaching a defining moment in Michigan's future. Most want to do the right thing, but many are reluctant to make the hard decisions if it means they risk defeat the next time around.
What's needed is leadership --and the task of leadership is to find ways to put aside narrow partisanship and construct those small spaces in which lawmakers have some freedom of choice.
Freedom, that is, to do what they know is right.
What would make that a lot easier for our elected officials to do their work would be if the public is given a chance to be heard from.
By this I do NOT mean public opinion polls. Here's how America Speaks, a non-profit organization promoting citizen involvement, puts it,
"Unfortunately, polling is woefully inadequate for building a healthy democracy. Polls provide decision-makers with aggregate data about citizens' opinions, but do nothing to identify or help build a collective view upon which decision makers can reasonably act.
"They survey opinions without providing any way for people to learn or to be challenged. In the end, a public that has no opportunity to deeply engage with an issue (and only registers its opinions in snap judgments made to pollsters) will always be a ripe target for manipulation and influence."
Right now, when our future as a state is teetering in the balance, we desperately need civic education and public engagement. After all, it's our Michigan, and our elected officials have a responsibility to consider carefully our thoughts and feelings, just as we have an obligation to be well informed.
There are lots of ways to do this. Reading the newspapers or surfing the web. Going to town hall meetings. Writing to our elected Representatives and Senators in Lansing. Talking and telling - in coffee shops, malls, anywhere - of our hopes and fears for our Michigan and saying what we wish would happen to allow our children and grandchildren to continue to live here, in our home state. That's truly the democratic process, as the Founding Fathers saw it. Now as then, it is a process whose time has come. Join it.
***
Phil Power is a longtime observer of politics, economics and education issues in Michigan, and was a regent of the University of Michigan from 1987 to 1999. He is also president and founder of The Center for Michigan, a moderate think-and-do tank. These opinions and others expressed in his columns are his own and do not in any way represent official policy positions of The Center for Michigan. Phil would be pleased to hear from readers at ppower@hcnnet.com Phil Power is a longtime observer of politics, economics and education issues in Michigan.



One Comment
Ohhh, the poor politicians...remember when 60 minutes used to show these overworked politicians on junkets to lavish resorts, golfing, dining, etc, and inflating their own expense account amounts. Remember the Congressional Post Office scandal when they were taking out loans and not repaying them. Remember when Gov. Milliken and Michigan went through the downgrading of Michigan's bond ratings and those lavish expenditures to redo the Capitol building. Remember how the politicians created the method for their salaries to increase not by the voters but the politicians themselves NOT voting to prevent the raises. The politicians waste our tax payments because it doesn't come out of their pockets and because people like you think that it's so hard to be a politician and supposedly running from meeting to meeting to represent us. They're not. They're rushing to another lobbyist's lobster and steak dinner or getting a lobbyist to give their wive, child or friend a high-paying job. They're accepting graft and kickbacks to create and pass favorable bills for those lobbyists instead of fixing the problems that have been around forever.
Remember how the insurance industry has gouged and raised premiums to obscene levels under Gov. Engler and the rigged contract deal he gave EDS and in exchange for a cushy job after he left office.
Trying reading just a sample of a few of the reports of cheating going on by these harried politicians supposedly serving (NOT) the public citizens of states across the nation at http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/keyword?k=CRONIES
Please don't tell us how we need to appreciate these people who go into the political arena and then learn to feed at the public trough. Instead, help us point the finger at those politicians that need to be recalled and each one that replaces that one to be recalled until they learn that they need to actually represent the voters otherwise they should get fired (recalled) until the message is loud and clear.
Things in our political system won't change until the people learn to use this mechanism to fire these self-serving politicians and actually have to work everyday accomplishing things that satisfy their employers, the voters, just the way the voters have to work and perform or get fired at their jobs.
Post a Comment